Biden wants to impose more taxes on stock buybacks- should Shahbaz too?

News Image

A A H Soomro | March 09, 2024 at 11:21 AM GMT+05:00

0:00

March 09, 2024 (MLN): "He (Biden) also wants to quadruple the tax companies must pay when they buy back their stock to 4% from 1%."

This caught the idea of your author. Buybacks have been rampant globally and with recent ease in Pakistan - coupled with dirt-cheap valuations - a lot of sponsors have been grabbing the opportunity wherever possible.

Yes, these are certain lazy executives/sponsors who would rather buy shares through front men/women instead of giving benefits to minority shareholders. 

Nearly PKR 46B worth of shares have been bought through buybacks on PSX and major sponsor buying (HBL's through AKFED). The quantum is substantial according to Pakistan's standard with the likes of HBL, Engro, Lucky Cement, Maple Leaf, Bank Alfalah, JDW Sugar, TPL Properties, Synthetic Products (SPEL) and NETSOL.

This is a good beginning as it offers investors opportunities to exit while determining pseudo floor prices on valuation. 

But of course, sponsors do it to make money for themselves in the medium to long term. There is clear gain which is expected to be made from such transactions. And yes mostly the gain goes to rich sponsors who happen to hold most of the control and shareholding(s) with some benefit to minority shareholders.

Inequality in income needs to be tamed one way or another. Maybe tax only the majority shareholders, you decide. 

The merits of taxing the buyback are 1) it's a tax on the elite 2) it's a tax on expected profits 3) it's better than a tax on bonus shares (extremely absurd) 4) nudges companies to invest in long-term growth 5) better utilized in the form of dividend and let minority shareholders decide where to invest.  

So should it be taxed like Biden envisions? Probably not. But arguments do exist when salaried classes are being further squeezed. 

The author is an independent economic analyst and writes on Twitter and Linkedin.

Related News

Name Price/Vol %Chg/NChg
KSE100 157,953.47
553.57M
1.14%
1775.65
ALLSHR 96,741.22
1,950.59M
1.16%
1110.83
KSE30 48,198.94
248.77M
1.09%
520.47
KMI30 232,694.17
289.62M
1.31%
3011.94
KMIALLSHR 65,027.13
1,016.35M
1.03%
660.37
BKTi 42,489.56
83.86M
1.35%
566.75
OGTi 31,779.36
15.18M
0.14%
43.57
Symbol Bid/Ask High/Low
Name Last High/Low Chg/%Chg
BITCOIN FUTURES 117,600.00 118,295.00
116,115.00
1775.00
1.53%
BRENT CRUDE 67.36 68.16
67.34
-0.59
-0.87%
RICHARDS BAY COAL MONTHLY 84.00 0.00
0.00
-0.40
-0.47%
ROTTERDAM COAL MONTHLY 94.50 94.50
94.50
0.95
1.02%
USD RBD PALM OLEIN 1,106.50 1,106.50
1,106.50
0.00
0.00%
CRUDE OIL - WTI 63.13 63.91
63.11
-0.57
-0.89%
SUGAR #11 WORLD 16.18 16.27
16.15
-0.09
-0.55%

Chart of the Day


Latest News
September 18, 2025 at 03:19 PM GMT+05:00

Pakistan records $245m Current Account Deficit in August


September 18, 2025 at 03:17 PM GMT+05:00

Pakistan’s mining sector seen as key driver of $8bn


September 18, 2025 at 02:43 PM GMT+05:00

Gold price in Pakistan remain unchanged


September 18, 2025 at 02:26 PM GMT+05:00

Oil prices slip as fed rate cut sparks economic concerns


September 18, 2025 at 02:15 PM GMT+05:00

Power generation rises 8% YoY in August 2025



Top 5 things to watch in this week

Pakistan Stock Movers
Name Last Chg/%Chg
Name Last Chg/%Chg