June 19, 2020: EU leaders launched fraught negotiations Friday, deeply divided over how to raise and then distribute a major recovery fund to revive a European economy ravaged by the coronavirus pandemic.
Europe faces its biggest recession in the bloc's 63-year history, and states are under pressure to look beyond their own borders and to find ways to lift the whole continent.
On the table at Friday's virtual summit is a proposal from European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen for a 750-billion-euro ($840-billion) rescue fund that, if accepted, would mark a historic milestone for EU unity.
“We have a collective responsibility to deliver,” summit host Charles Michel, president of the leaders' European Council, said on Twitter. “Now is the time to engage.”
But opposition is fierce from countries known as the “frugal four” — The Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark and Austria — who have promised to fight deep into the summer to rein in the spending.
“It is clear that we expect no essential agreements at this summit,” said a government official in Germany, which takes over the EU's rotating presidency on July 1 and will drive the negotiations.
“We know about the difficulties. This will be a big piece of work,” the official said.
A French source called it a “warm-up round” that would “take the temperature” before leaders land a compromise in late July.
Lined up against the frugals are EU countries such as Italy and Spain that were the first and hardest hit by the pandemic, and quickly asked for help from their better-off partners.
Crippled with overstretched finances, these countries lack the ability to fight the recession with a wave of extra spending and are looking for a highly visible act of solidarity.
The commission's plan is inspired by a German and French proposal in which EU money is raised on the financial markets to spend Europe-wide in the biggest slice of joint borrowing ever undertaken by the union.
By endorsing the plan, German Chancellor Angela Merkel broke Germany's long-held taboo against pan-European pooled borrowing, catching the “frugals” off guard.
They have vowed nonetheless to fight on, most notably in insisting that the funds should be released as loans with strict conditions and not as grants or subsidies.
Speaking in the Swedish parliament on Thursday, Prime Minister Stefan Lofven said the money needed to be repaid and quickly or otherwise leaders would be “sending the bill to future taxpayers.”
In an interview with AFP, the Italian Prime Minister tried to assuage these concerns, assuring that the money would build “a better Italy” that would be more modern and greener.To help pay for the recovery plan, the proposal floats EU-wide taxation on big tech, or carbon emissions, to provide the European Commission with funds of its own.
A recovery plan without own-resources would be like “a motor without petrol”, a European source warned.
But this too could prove too controversial for several member states that are loath to see the EU financially self-sufficient and too close in spirit to a federal government like in the United States.
Complicating matters still further, the recovery fund is linked to the EU's long-term, a seven-year budget that is being negotiated in parallel.
This has countries usually on the receiving end of EU spending — many in eastern Europe — worried that funds that historically came their way could be cut because of the recovery plan and they have also threatened to block the talks.
After this first round, the EU Council head Michel will launch consultations with a view to one or two new summits in July in Brussels, this time in person.
A face-to-face meeting between leaders, with well-timed breaks and asides, is considered indispensable to reach a compromise on such a complex issue, where unanimity is required.